Cast:
Michael PeñaMr. Roarke
Maggie QGwen Olsen
Lucy HaleMelanie Cole
Michael RookerDamon
Austin StowellPatrick Sullivan
Jimmy O. YangBrax WeaverDirector:
Jeff Wadlow
Fantasy Island (2020): Spoiler-Free Review
Fantasy Island is Jeff Wadlow’s 2020 horror thriller about a resort where wishes go wrong. It reimagines a classic TV series as a twisty puzzle.
The Premise
Mr. Roarke (Michael Peña) runs a luxury resort where guests live out their wildest fantasies. A group of lucky winners arrives for a weekend. Their wishes begin to go wrong, and they must work out the island’s secret before it is too late.
Why It Works
- The film turns a classic TV idea into a horror puzzle.
- The cast includes Maggie Q, Lucy Hale, Austin Stowell, Portia Doubleday and Jimmy O. Yang.
At a Glance
- Director: Jeff Wadlow
- Cast: Michael Peña, Maggie Q, Lucy Hale, Austin Stowell, Portia Doubleday
- Source: The 1977 TV series Fantasy Island
- Producer: Blumhouse
Verdict
A silly, twisty horror thriller for a casual night. Do not expect deep scares.
- Who should watch: Fans of the original series and light horror.
- Spoilers: none. We never reveal the twist in this review.
Frequently Asked Questions About:
"Fantasy Island"
Is Fantasy Island based on a TV show?
Yes. It reimagines the 1977 series.
Is Fantasy Island scary?
It is more twisty than scary, with some jump scares.
Last updated: November, 2026
– Film details and cast information checked.







