Cast:
Dylan McDermottDon
Charlie PlummerTyler
Samantha MathisCindy
Madisen BeatyKassi
Brenna ShermanSusie
Lance Chantiles-WertzBillyThe Clovehitch Killer (2018): Spoiler-Free Review
The Clovehitch Killer is Duncan Skiles’s 2018 thriller about a teenager and a dark secret at home. It is quiet, slow and hard to forget.
The Premise
Tyler (Charlie Plummer) is a teenager in a small town. His father, Don (Dylan McDermott), is a kind scout leader and a pillar of the church. A killer, known as the Clovehitch Killer, terrorized the town ten years ago, then vanished. One day Tyler finds a strange set of photographs hidden in his dad’s truck, and he starts to ask hard questions.
Why It Works
- Dylan McDermott plays a gentle, friendly father with a chilling calm.
- Charlie Plummer makes Tyler’s doubt and fear feel real.
- The film builds suspense from small, quiet scenes instead of shock.
At a Glance
- Director: Duncan Skiles
- Cast: Dylan McDermott, Charlie Plummer, Samantha Mathis, Madisen Beaty
- Setting: A small American town
- Genre: Crime thriller
Verdict
A tense, thoughtful thriller with strong acting. It aims for dread, not gore. If you like stories where a teenager uncovers a parent’s dark secret at home, check out Run next.
- Who should watch: Fans of slow crime dramas and psychological suspense.
- Spoilers: none. We never reveal the twist in this review.
The Clovehitch Killer Ending Explained
⚠️ Major spoilers ahead! ⚠️
Tyler’s suspicions are confirmed when he discovers a hidden crawlspace under his father’s workshop containing dark souvenirs from the victims, women’s underwear, and polaroids. Don catches Tyler poking around and attempts to gaslight him, claiming the fetish materials belong to Don’s “sick” brother, Ernie.
The movie then rewinds halfway through to show the events from Don’s perspective: Don is indeed the Clovehitch Killer, and his urge to murder has returned after a ten-year hiatus. Don kidnaps a local woman and ties her up in his basement, but before he can kill her, Tyler and Kassi intervene. Kassi sneaks into the house, overpowers Don, and rescues the woman, while Tyler confronts his father at gunpoint in the woods.
Instead of turning Don over to the police—which would destroy their family’s reputation, bankrupt his mother, and turn Tyler and his sister into social outcasts forever—Tyler and Kassi execute a cold, calculated cover-up.
Tyler shoots his father dead in the woods, making it look like a tragic hunting accident. Tyler and Kassi then plant the Clovehitch murder souvenirs inside the house of Don’s estranged, paralyzed brother, framing him post-mortem for the historic killings.
The film ends with a chilling montage: the town holds a massive, solemn funeral honoring Don Burnside as a beloved community leader and scoutmaster. Tyler gives a glowing eulogy praising his father’s Christian values and integrity, keeping his father’s horrific true identity a secret forever to protect his family’s normal life.
Frequently Asked Questions About:
"The Clovehitch Killer"
Who directed The Clovehitch Killer?
Duncan Skiles directed it.
Is The Clovehitch Killer based on a true story?
It is fiction, but it echoes real cases of killers who lived a normal life.
Who stars in The Clovehitch Killer?
Dylan McDermott and Charlie Plummer star.
Is The Clovehitch Killer gory?
No. It focuses on tension, not blood.







